Long distance couples — the part nobody warns you about is the reunion

Start with the good news, because it is better than you have been told and almost nothing written about this says it. Long distance relationships are not fragile, they are not doomed, and the people in them are not doing worse. The difficulty arrives somewhere else entirely.

Three separate samples say the same thing. In a nationally representative survey of 870 people, those in long distance relationships reported higher relationship quality and higher dedication, and felt less trapped — and by follow-up they had broken up at the same rate as everybody else. A second study of more than a thousand people found so few differences that its authors concluded people at a distance are simply not at a disadvantage. Their outcomes did not even vary with how often they visited.

There is one neat, slightly ominous detail in the first of those. People at a distance were more confident their relationship would last. And it lasted exactly as often.

What the distance actually takes

Every piece of advice on this subject assumes the missing thing is contact, which is why every remedy is a way of adding contact back: more calls, a shared calendar, a countdown, a film watched at the same time.

Listen to what people at a distance actually describe, though, and it is not about longing at all. In a set of interviews with students in long distance relationships, the researchers isolated a theme they called compensating for the lack of context:

… we don’t have like stuff we can talk about, like, stuff that we did earlier that day. You know, be like, “Oh, remember that weird waiter we had?!” So it’s kind of hard.

“Andrea”, in Firmin, Firmin & Merical (2013)

I think that sometimes there are little holes in the other person’s life, because you can’t tell them everything. There isn’t time.

another participant, same study

It is a small study — sixteen students at one university, all of them women — so take the numbers in it for nothing and the words in it for everything. Nobody in either of those quotes is missing anybody. What is missing is the boring, accumulating, shared record of a day that two people in one house get for free and never notice they have. And that is the one thing you cannot schedule into existence — you can add an hour of video, you cannot add the weird waiter.

The problem is not the amount of contact. It is that the contact is all highlights, and a relationship is mostly not highlights.

A woman lying in bed at night, her face lit by the phone she is holding above her.
Most of it happens here, at the end of a day the other person did not see.

The reunion

Now the part that genuinely deserves a warning, and that we have not seen on a single page about long distance relationships.

A study followed long distance dating couples through the transition to living in the same place. From its own abstract: about half of them make that transition, while the other half end the relationship during the separation. And among the couples who do reunite, one-third end within three months of it.

What happens to 100 long distance dating couples

Ended during the separation

50never reunited

Reunited, still together after three months

~33the ones who make it

Reunited, ended within three months

~17the group nobody mentions

From Stafford, Merolla & Castle (2006). The abstract gives two figures — about half end during the separation, and one-third of reunited couples end within three months of reunion. The second and third rows here are that arithmetic applied to a hundred couples, not numbers the paper prints. It studied dating couples, mostly students, so read it as the shape of the risk rather than as your odds.

The reason is the interesting bit. What the couples reported losing at reunion was not intimacy — it was autonomy, novelty, anticipation, and control over their own time. Around eighty-five per cent said they had lost at least one thing they had valued about being apart. And what they gained, in the paper’s phrasing, was increased positive and negative knowledge of each other, and what it calls the dissipation of quixotic ideals.

Which is the whole thing in one sentence. At a distance you are both working from the best available information about the other person, and the best available information is flattering. Couples apart idealise each other measurably more than couples together do — and idealisation is not a delusion you should feel foolish about, it is what happens when the gaps get filled in by inference.

Why it feels closer, and why that is the same fact

There is a well-known finding that long distance couples report more intimacy than couples living together, which gets quoted a lot and is usually presented as reassurance. It is real. It is also the same mechanism as the reunion problem, sent in a different bill.

The account that explains both is that limited, asynchronous communication lets each of you present a better-composed version of yourself, and lets the other fill every gap with a generous guess. That is why it can feel warmer than being in a kitchen together — and it is exactly the thing that reunion takes away. So “we are closer than we have ever been” is true, and it is not a prediction.

A related phrase from the research is worth carrying around: couples at a distance postpone realistic assessments. Not avoid. Postpone.

About the 7% thing

Since the subject is tone dying in text, it is worth dealing with the statistic you have certainly met: that communication is 7% words, 38% tone, 55% body language. It is on nearly every page about long distance, and it is not a finding.

It comes from two small experiments published in 1967. In the first, thirty participants heard two women read out nine single words — dear, thanks, honey, maybe, oh, really, brute, don’t, terrible — in different tones, and judged the speaker’s attitude. Tone beat the word. In the second, people compared tone of voice with photographs of faces. The photograph beat the tone.

Read that again: the second study contained no words at all. The two experiments never shared a channel, and the famous percentages were produced by combining them into a single formula afterwards. As a peer-reviewed analysis of the rule puts it, the coefficients were arrived at “arbitrary without being supported by a study”.

Tone really is hard to carry in writing. Nine words read aloud by two women in 1967 is just not the evidence for it, and a page that quotes the number has not read anything.

What to actually do

Four things, and only one of them is about contact.

Know where it ends, and be glad about the ending

This is the one piece of standard advice the evidence supports, and it supports it strongly. Outcomes did not vary with how often couples visited. What mattered was certainty about whether they would end up in the same place — and, separately, how happy each of them was about that particular future. Being sure and unhappy is not the same as being sure.

The best-evidenced one

Send the boring half

If what is missing is shared context rather than contact, then the fix is not another hour of video — it is the unremarkable stuff you would not bother to report. The queue in the post office. What the neighbour said. The waiter. That material feels too small to send, which is precisely why it is the material that has gone missing.

The one nobody does

Stop saving the difficult subject for the call

Couples at a distance batch their hard conversations into the weekly video call, which is how the one good hour becomes the hour you dread. A call is synchronous and performed. It is a bad place to start something and an even worse place to be interrupted in the middle of it.

Every week

Answer at the same time, not in turn

Asynchronous does not have to mean sequential. If you both answer the same question without seeing the other’s answer first, the time difference stops being a disadvantage: they answer at breakfast, you answer at midnight, and neither answer was shaped by the other one. The thirty-six questions work much better this way, and so does the unromantic material — who is flying next, what the money is for, when this ends.

Better across time zones

And plan the reunion as a transition

Given the numbers above, the single most useful thing on this page may be this: treat moving in together as a beginning with its own difficulty, rather than as the finish line the whole relationship has been counting down to.

The specific losses are known in advance — autonomy, novelty, control of your own evenings — and they are losses even when you are delighted to be there. Saying that out loud to each other beforehand costs nothing, and it is a great deal easier than discovering at week six that you both miss something you are not supposed to miss.

Where inbetween fits, and where it does not

It is not a video app and will not replace one. It is for the part in between the calls. You write to it, they write to it, and it is the only one who hears both sides — so nothing crosses unless you allow it, and the message sent at one in the morning, tired and hurt, which would arrive while they are asleep and be the first thing they read, can go somewhere it will be understood without being delivered.

It is also built for answering at the same time rather than in turn, which is the thing that makes a seven-hour time difference stop mattering. The games run on the same mechanic.

What it cannot do is manufacture shared context. Nothing can. That part is on you, and it is mostly a matter of sending the small stuff.

Where this came from

  1. Stafford, L., Merolla, A. J. & Castle, J. D. (2006). When long-distance dating partners become geographically close. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 23(6), 901–919.
  2. Stafford, L. & Merolla, A. J. (2007). Idealization, reunions, and stability in long-distance dating relationships. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 24(1), 37–54.
  3. Kelmer, G., Rhoades, G. K., Stanley, S. & Markman, H. J. (2013). Relationship quality, commitment, and stability in long-distance relationships. Family Process, 52(2), 257–270.
  4. Dargie, E., Blair, K. L., Goldfinger, C. & Pukall, C. F. (2015). Go long! Predictors of positive relationship outcomes in long-distance dating relationships. Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy, 41(2), 181–202.
  5. Jiang, L. C. & Hancock, J. T. (2013). Absence makes the communication grow fonder: geographic separation, interpersonal media, and intimacy in dating relationships. Journal of Communication, 63(3), 556–577.
  6. Walther, J. B. (1996). Computer-mediated communication: impersonal, interpersonal, and hyperpersonal interaction. Communication Research, 23(1), 3–43.
  7. Mehrabian, A. & Wiener, M. (1967). Decoding of inconsistent communications. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 6(1), 109–114.
  8. Mehrabian, A. & Ferris, S. R. (1967). Inference of attitudes from nonverbal communication in two channels. Journal of Consulting Psychology, 31(3), 248–252.
  9. Amsel, T. T. (2019). An urban legend called: the 7/38/55 ratio rule. European Polygraph, 13(2), 95–99.
  10. Firmin, M. W., Firmin, R. L. & Merical, K. L. (2013). Extended communication efforts involved with college long-distance relationships. Contemporary Issues in Education Research, 6(1), 97–106 — sixteen interviews, the source of the two quotes above.